PIRIFORMIS SYNDROME (PAIN in the BUTT)

The Piriformis muscle (piriformis; “pear shaped“) is a tiny muscle located deep in the buttocks, underneath the gluteal muscles.  This little muscle is the most well-known of a group of muscles known as the “Hip Rotator Cuff” and is frequently the source of the pain in the butt and leg pain.

Piriformis Syndrome is a miserable condition in which the Piriformis Muscle becomes overly tight.  Although there are almost always underlying biomechanical issues to deal with (valgus / varus knees, high / low arches, etc) this pathological tightness of the Piriformis is usually the result of FASCIAL ADHESIONS, TENDINOSIS, or a nasty combination of both. 

Piriformis Syndrome can be aggravated by bending, lifting, sitting, sports, and even driving (foot on the gas pedal).  Contrary to what your M.D. might tell you, there are no drugs or surgeries that are effective for treating Piriformis Syndrome. I will warn you, in 20 plus years of practice I have never one time seen a person whose Piriformis Release Surgery actually worked. 

Piriformis Muscle Syndrome

Photo by Beth Ohara

Piriformis Syndrome is an extremely common condition, and is far more likely to be found in women than men (about 12-15 times more often).  Although I can only speculate on the reason for this, I suspect that it is a child-bearing issue. It probably also has to do with the naturally wider shape of a woman’s pelvis. This is the most likely explanation for my finding it much more frequently in women than men —- even in women who have not had children. 

As I stated earlier, Piriformis Syndrome is a major cause of sciatica (leg pain, numbness, tingling, or weakness, in any combination), hip pain, and buttock pain.  Because sciatica is so often involved, Piriformis Syndrome is usually misdiagnosed as a slipped disc, herniated disc, or a chronic low back or sacroilliac problem.

The sciatic nerve is both the largest and longest nerve in the body, and at its largest point is about the thickness of one’s thumb.  The sciatic nerve originates in the low back (lumbar spine region) and angles toward the middle of the buttock.  It then extends down through the leg, passing underneath the piriformis muscle.  Be aware that in as much as half the population, the sciatic nerve travels through the Piriformis Muscle, passes over the Piriformis Muscle, or splits in two and passes directly around the Piriformis Muscle. 

f

Piriformis Syndrome

Piriformis Syndrome causes sciatica.  The sciatic nerve runs all the way to the foot

f

Piriformis Syndrome Sciatica

Note the biggest part of the sciatic nerve near the top of the picture.  The muscle that runs across the page just above the sciatic nerve is the Piriformis Muscle.

The symptoms of Piriformis Syndrome usually begin as a deep aching in what women like to refer to as their “hip” area.  This pain will be found along an imaginary line that runs from the very tip top of the butt crack, to the greater trochanter of the hip bone (the bony knob on the upper and portion of the outer or lateral thigh).

A significant predisposing factor to chronic contracture and microscopic scarring of the piriformis muscle is wearing cruddy or improper footwear for your foot type (high-arched people wearing a “stability” or “dual-density” shoe). Other people predisposed to Piriformis Syndrome includes those with faulty spinal or lower limb mechanics, being overweight, having poor posture, spending too much time sitting, spending too much time on concrete, not partaking in enough physical activity (or occasionally too much exercise — over-training).  And of course, the biggie — just being female. 

Due to mechanical stresses causing chronic tightness / contracture, the Piriformis Muscle can actually become shortened over time.  This often results in microscopic scarring of the fascial sheaths that tightly surround the muscle itself.  Piriformis Syndrome is most commonly worse at rest (sitting or lying down) and is often (but not always) relieved temporarily, by moderate activity (particularly walking or stretching).

For years, I did not really understand why I had such good clinical results with so many cases of buttock / hip pain and sciatica, while other seemingly identical cases were largely unresponsive to chiropractic adjustments.  Frequently these “problem” cases would get fantastic short-term results from their adjustment, but these results never seemed to last more than a few days at the most (and often no more than a few hours).  It was not until I started doing “TISSUE REMODELING” in 2001, that I truly began to understand what was going on in many of these cases. 

Over the past decade I have come to realize that Piriformis Syndrome is literally “epidemic” in the female portion of our society.  Although I had no intention for it to happen this way, our Piriformis Syndrome Page is Destroy Chronic Pain’s #1 webpage by far.  And despite all of the new research on the subject, the medical community remains largely mystified about what it really is, or how to treat it effectively.  Again, drugs and surgery do not constitute “effective treatment” for Piriformis Syndrome.  Never assume that a “Piriformis Release Surgery” will solve your problems!

SCAR TISSUE AND ITS RELATIONSHIP TO

PIRIFORMIS SYNDROME

As you have read, scar tissue is normal, elastic tissue (think nicely combed hair here) that has been disrupted from its organized structure, into a balled-up and tangled wad of inflexible and hyper-sensitive, micro-gristle (think of a hair tangle that cannot be combed out).  When it comes to Piriformis Syndrome, this kind of microscopic scar tissue is not typically in the muscle belly itself, but in the Fascia.  Fascia is the thin, but very tough, yellowish white membranes that cover muscles.  In my neck of the Ozarks, deer hunters call these membranes, “Striffin“.

Fascia is arguably the single most pain-sensitive tissue in the body!  Fascial Adhesions will cause pain and dysfunction.  Destroy Fascial Adhesions and Destroy Chronic Pain!

Because most of these scar tissues are in the fascia as opposed to the muscle itself, they do not image on MRI.  It is my opinion that microscopic scarring of the Piriformis Muscle is the single most common cause of chronic, long-standing, Sacroilliac or buttock pain (the Sacroilliac Joints are the bony bumps that lie just up and lateral to the top of the butt crack).  It is also the most common cause of what I was calling a “butt-based” sciatica twenty years ago.

Piriformis Syndrome

Photo by Anatomist90

Piriformis Syndrome Sciatica

Photo by Anatomist90

FOR MORE INFORMATION ABOUT PIRIFORMIS SYNDROME, VISIT THE WEBSITE OF DR RUSSELL SCHIERLING

14 Responses to PIRIFORMIS SYNDROME (PAIN in the BUTT)

  1. Joan Nishite

    Piriformis syndrome, I have never heard of it before, but I have had these symptoms for most of my life. Thank you for the information. Great job!

  2. Ljay

    Funny I’ve read this post probably 5-10 times and I think that each time something will jump out and magically fix me. I’ve suffered from excruciatingly chronic pain for 13 years. Had two hip ops, 15 injections and pretty much broke from all the weekly treatments I have in an attempt to keep me sain. Like others it has sucked the life out of me, I’ve quite my job and suffering from depression. If there is ANY advice you can offer I’d appreciate it. Apparently my piriformis looked ok under the knife but my nerve was severely swollen and irritated- my question, well something caused that so why didn’t ou wok that out while ou had a 12cm incision in my butt open!!!?? I am basically begging for help- ain meds and Pilates don’t help :(

  3. Shalene Harriss

    THANK YOU!! I am going to take this article with me to my doctor who says nothibg is wrong with me! I am so glad i came across this!!!!!!

  4. Lynn L.

    This is very interesting. I’ve been experiencing pain in the exact areas as described for several years now. I’ve attributed my pain to my scoliosis, thinking it’s something I have to “live with.” Now that the pain has gotten progressively worse, I’ve been trying to get a diagnosis for over six months. First doc said it was a pinched nerve. Second doc said it was SI Joint dysfunction. I’ve had MRI’s, CT scans, x-rays and ultrasounds, and just found out yesterday I have “tendenosis” in my gluteus medius tendon (aka dead butt syndrome?). I can’t help but think I also have piriformis problems, along with “snapping hip syndrome.” I’ve tried PT, pain killers, ice packs, warm packs, hot tubs, acupuncture and SI joint injections – and I have no relief for any of this. I’m desperate to know what I can do to relieve the pain, both short term and long term. I can’t sit for very long and standing/walking for more than about 5 minutes is wildly painful. I also find my right leg (below the knee cap) and right foot start to perspire when my piriformus/dead butt syndrome is acting up. I’m going to a teaching hospital tomorrow to meet with a “top doc” intervention radiologist. Hopefully, he can do something to help me. This chronic, intractable pain is excrutiating and is sucking my will to live. Thanks for this post. It’s very helpful. :-)

  5. Laura

    Thank you so much for this great article. I was misdiagnosed with fibromyalgia yesterday and I had to laugh when I read what the symptoms are. I haven’t had chronic pain for more than 3 months, it is acute and happens when I bend or twist, then that piriformis muscle goes crazy spasming and I can’t get it to unlock. It then squeezes my piformis so hard that I can’t sit, drive a car, or stand for long periods of time. My own mother, a registered nurse, did not buy that I had FM either. I have suffered from low back pain and shoulder pain on my right side since I was a child. The earliest children are usually diagnosed with FM is in their teens. The doctor also did not do a tender points test. I had to laugh when he gave me 4 bottles of Cymbalta for free. I guess he had his MO. Make me wait an hour to see him, then slap me with some blanket chronic pain diagnosis rather than take a full medical history. Well I have flat feet, and my right leg is slightly shorter than the other, which causes all the problems and sciatica like symptoms on my right side. When I saw a podiatrist for orthotics in 2009, he informed me that the flat feet would cause my lower back pain if I didn’t wear the orthotics every day with a quality shoe. My chiropractor said it was a muscle in my back that was shorter in women than in men, but she didn’t tell me what muscle it was. This article helped me to put all the pieces together. Thank you so much for writing this article, I only wish more doctors were as knowledgable so I didn’t have to waste my time.

  6. Anna

    Dear Dr. Russ-
    I am a 20 year old female and occasionally (2x a month maybe..) have a very deep pain in my left butt cheek (very rarely in my right). It’s not to the point where I can’t function but it is a pain that is noticeable. If I press down on my buttcheek, it feels tender and sore, like I’ve fallen on it but that’s never the case, it’s just a pain that comes and goes for no real reason. What you’ve written above sounds like it could be what my problem is but I’m just wondering if women my age get this? Am I too young to have this? I have had a child and understand this could’ve controbuted to my issue… Will it continue to get worse? Thanks for reading and for writing this interesting and informative article!

  7. Pauline Atkin, Chester England

    At last…..a diagnosis!!! I cannot begin to tell you how much peace of mind I feel having read your ‘Pain in the Butt’ website.
    Since 2008 I have attended different clinics within our local hospital to no avail. I have spinal stenosis, apparently my lumbar facet joints are ‘rubbish’, & all forms of treatment thus far have failed, i.e. spinal & root nerve injections, medications etc.. Despite all my hip area pain, no osteo arthritis manifests itself. Now I know why!!
    I feel I can cope now I know what is causing the pain.
    THANK YOU SO MUCH DR RUSS!

  8. Val2081

    Thank you for such an in depth and interesting article on butt pain. The pics could be exactly where my pain is. I feel I now know what I am up against and understand better how I can cope with it.

  9. Thank you for the your remarkable comments and opinions on Piriformis Syndrome. My closest relative, my Uncle Donald (we are both English) he’s now retired and close to 80 years, (but as mentally sharp and physically active as ever) like myself, I’m still chasing news, he spent most of his life as a War War Correspondent. In 1971 after suffering a concussion after a land mine explosion in Vietnam, he had a Laminectomy performed in Tokyo where fusion lower lumbar fusion was used.He appeared to fully recover and was left with his ‘left leg’ shorter than the other. It never stopped him from playing sports and being very active and pursuing his career until retirement.

    As his eyesight is failing (Glucoma) he had a few falls,nothing dramatic, but in the last year. Result seems to have been all the symptoms of sciatica in his right hip radiating down the front of his leg.

    Unlike many cases of Piriformis Syndrome, his symptoms occur when lying down – in any position – walking or sitting upright in a chair removes the pain.

    Xrays and MRI show little but the slight lower lumbar deterioration – an area he has had minor aches in. for 20 years.

    Apropos treatment, strong pain killers bring little or no relief. Many Physiotherapists along with countless doctors seem stumped. Cortisone injections failed. All Surgeons talk surgical exploration. into the Piriformis muscle. An old friend of his a former MASH surgeon advises him against it at his age. Biggest problem he has is he can’t lie down to get sleep. Obviously he can’t sit up all night or walk to removed the pain.

    I worry about this dilemma as every specialist has had a different opinion?

  10. Przedłużanie Rzęs Warszawa

    I have been surfing online greater than 3 hours today, yet I never discovered any interesting article like yours. It is lovely price enough for me. In my opinion, if all site owners and bloggers made excellent content material as you did, the internet might be a lot more helpful than ever before.

  11. Margie Achman

    After 14 years of wildland firefighting, working in and running a commercial greenhouse’s for many years, volunteering, becoming an employee with the Red Cross, and being a very busy Mom, Wife and person in general, I started having a pain in my butt. We moved to Missouri over a year ago from Alaska where I had a great Chiropractor, Heather — hard shoes to fill. I asked around and found Dr. Schierling – heard he was the best! My large family in Missouri all go to him and even family outside the state when they come visit. Anyway he had been doing adjustments and I, as usual, complained to him about my pain in the butt. The pain was so bad I could not sit, stand or lay on my side. Driving would make me cry! We set up an appointment for the Tissue Remodeling Treatment. Trust me the first 3 minutes were not fun, but immediately it stopped hurting. The bruising wasn’t pretty, but boy I would walk, sit, stand and yes, drive! Best thing I ever did. Haven’t had the pain back since and that was 8 months ago – Thanks Dr. Schierling!

  12. I had a pain in my butt that ran down to my knees. It got so bad I was taking pain meds every day and sitting or standing was painful. Even though I had been to going to Dr. Schierling for adjustments and had him do the remodeling for my neck, I did not realize that he could do anything about the sciatic nerve that was causing me so much pain. After just one soft tissue treatment I was pain free and did not need a second treatment. I am now going back to see if Dr. Schierling can relieve the pain in my heel from my fallen arches. I am so thankful our family has Dr. Schierling in our lives!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s